Welsh Rugby

  • Home
  • Rugby
  • RIP The WRU Two Club Plan For Welsh Rugby . . . Another Dead Parrot

RIP The WRU Two-Club Plan for Welsh Rugby . . . Another Dead Parrot

A giant dead parrot. Pic. Alamy

A giant dead parrot. Pic. Alamy

The Welsh Rugby Union’s bold new world of two teams seems doomed before the sunrise as Graham Thomas reports.

 

There may still be six weeks to go until the Welsh Rugby Union firmly decides on the future of the professional game in Wales, but already the two-headed monster idea looks as dead as a dodo.

In the words of John Cleese, it has ceased to be. It is bereft of life. It is . . . an ex-parrot.

We know this because Dave Reddin has told us so.

Not in so many words, of course, but deep in the foliage of a flowery thicket of verse put out by the WRU at the popular PR burial time of Friday at 5.30pm, was a statement that read a little like an obituary.

Speaking about the WRU’s  so-called “optimal choice” of cutting the number of professional clubs from four to just two, Reddin, the Union’s director of rugby, said of the current consultation process,  “I don’t want to get ahead of myself or take any shortcuts here, but I can confidently say that our thinking is changing in positive ways as we progress.”

It would be a poor leader who announces a wide-ranging consultation process and then states that he intends to stick to his guns, regardless.

But even so, it’s quite early in the game to be quite that frank - midway through the consultation process, to admit, already, that your own baby is about to be thrown out with the bathwater.

READ MORE: Dragons Set Fire To WRU Plans Which Already Look Doomed

So what are these “positive ways” in which the Union’s views are changing?

Burying the notion of just two teams would seem to sum it up. 

The two-club model was not greeted with many hats flung high in the air and popped champagne corks when it was unveiled a month ago.

Since then, it has been excoriated by the Dragons after their meeting with the WRU and trampled underfoot by the Welsh Rugby Players Association.

Former players have also formed a longish queue to jump up and down on the document, just in case anyone might feel it was somehow still alive.

READ MORE: WRU Tells Fans: Let us Know What You Think of Our Plan

Even those fans who have engaged in the “public engagement survey” have pointed out how crudely slanted the questions are to giving the Union the information it thinks will justify its proposal.

Example: “I am in favour of making significant changes if this helps Welsh national and professional teams to return to winning ways.”

The only odd silence so far has come from the Scarlets and the Ospreys, who have yet to be as quick off the mark as the Dragons in publicly rejecting the plan.

This is more likely to be a tactical lip-sealing, brought on by feelings of vulnerability, than any conviction the plan has much merit. 

The two west Wales regions – who just happen to have most of the best players and have been the most successful teams in the URC -  are keeping their powder dry for the time being and letting their supporters get ready to ignite things with talk of protest marches that will attract local political backing.

All of which will leave the executive of the WRU with a dilemma that won’t take very long to resolve.

Do they press on with an idea opposed by three of the regions – as well as by the players of the now Union-owned Cardiff?

Forcing through changes that have little to no support would carry catastrophic risk. Imagine two shiny new teams, names and badges, with nowhere to play and no-one prepared to watch them.

Imagine, too, having to fund them entirely without benefactor support.

That kind of ballsy independence might appeal to some within the WRU, but the member clubs – who have so far mostly sat on the sidelines of this debate - would remind them it is they who would suffer the disastrous consequences.

READ MORE: Welcome to the WRU's New Show . . . Squid Game

All of which suggests the life has already gone out of the two-team plan and the most likely outcome will be the proposal to stick with four clubs, but with unequal funding.

Interestingly, that was exactly the position the Union instantly adopted earlier this year when the Scarlets and Ospreys refused to sign the new Professional Rugby Agreement (PRA).

To be fair, they would not be the first authority figures to knowingly propose something completely and utterly unacceptable, in order to pull back to the position they were seeking all along.

It’s how Donald Trump tries to do his US trade deals. 

Yell loudly to the crowd and the cameras and then compromise in a back office room.

READ MORE: The Man With "The Plan" . . . WRU Chief Dave Reddin Insists It's Two or Too Late

Related News

Cardiff earned a win on the opening weekend of the Super Rygbi Cymru season at RGC.

Dan Fish Proud of Cardiff’s Away-Day Resolve After Bonus-Point Win at RGC

Cardiff head coach Dan Fish hailed his players’ resolve after they began their Super Rygbi Cymru campaign with a 47-31 victory over RGC in Colwyn Bay.

David Roberts | Sep 16, 2025
Amber Stamp Dunstan

Putting a Welsh Stamp on the World Cup . . . Amber Stamp Dunstan

Wales will have at least one person involved in the Women’s World Cup quarter finals this weekend after Amber Stamp-Dunstan was named as an assistant referee for the clash between England and Scotland

David Roberts | Sep 13, 2025
Newport captain Ben Roach. Pic: Gareth Everett

Newport Seeking Revenge Mission Against Llandovery as Super Rygbi Cymru Kicks Off

In the fifth of our series on the new Super Rygbi Cymru season, Newport capatin Ben Roach tells Carl Field his team are out for revenge against Llandovery.

Carl Field | Sep 12, 2025
Harlequins coach Danny Wilson. Pic. Alamy

Danny Wilson: ‘Too Good an Opportunity to Turn Down’ – Harlequins Boss Joins Wales Coaching Team

Danny Wilson has claimed the chance to return to international rugby was impossible to resist after agreeing to leave Harlequins and become Steve Tandy’s first appointment as Wales head coach.

Paul Jones | Sep 12, 2025
Wales' Harry Rees-Weldon. Pic. Alamy

For Harry, Wales, and Ebbw Vale . . . The Cry is Super Rygbi Cymru

The second edition of Super Rygbi Cymru kicks off this weekend and in day four of his spotlight on the tournament, Carl Field talks to Wales U20s star, Harry Rees-Weldon.

Carl Field | Sep 11, 2025
RGC in action against Carmarthen Quins.

RGC Ready for Another Campaign of Long Trips but Fewer Slips

Rygbi Gogledd Cymru (RGC) are the northern outpost who refuse to be left on the margins of Super Rygbi Cymru, as Carl Field reports.

Carl Field | Sep 10, 2025