• Home
  • Football
  • Former Cardiff City Boss Malky Mackay Survives In Scottish Top Flight . . . With Help From An Ex Swan

Former Cardiff City Boss Malky Mackay Survives In Scottish Top Flight . . . With Help From An Ex-Swan

Cardiff City Stadium. Pic: Graham Hunt/Alamy Live News

Cardiff City Stadium. Pic: Graham Hunt/Alamy Live News

Former Cardiff City manager Malky Mackay had ex-Swansea City man Yan Dhanda to thank for keeping Stirling County in the Scottish Premier League. Mackay – who took Cardiff into the Premier League in 2013 – admitted it was one of the craziest games of his managerial career.

By David Parsons

Former Cardiff City manager Malky Mackay had ex-Swansea City man Yan Dhanda to thank for keeping Stirling County in the Scottish Premier League.

Mackay – who took Cardiff into the Premier League in 2013 – admitted it was one of the craziest games of his managerial career.

County were 3-0 down on aggregate with 20 minutes left of their Premiership play-off final second leg against Partick Thistle but ended up sealing a sudden-death penalty shoot-out victory three hours after kick-off in Dingwall.

Simon Murray netted 80 seconds after Yan Dhanda’s penalty to transform the complexion of the game and George Harmon put County 3-1 ahead on the day at the start of nine minutes of stoppage time.

There was VAR drama throughout the 90 minutes and chances at either end in extra time before both sides missed penalties in the shoot-out and sudden death. Josh Sims eventually sealed a 5-4 penalties win after Ross Laidlaw had saved Ross Docherty’s spot-kick.

Mackay said: “I actually had the Carling Cup final with Cardiff against Liverpool that went to penalties, and that was a mental game. But this was something else.

“This, being a two-legged play-off and having the responsibility of keeping this club in the Premiership, means a hell of a lot.

“Honestly, I never thought we wouldn’t win. Even at half-time I thought we could score three goals. If we got a goal, I thought they would take a step back and creak, and we would get the momentum, and that’s what happened.”

Mackay added: “As a manager it’s a huge achievement, because we’re a tiny club in the Premiership.

“I’ve read a lot of stuff, and there have been a lot of questions about how brilliant Partick Thistle have been, and they have done terrifically well. It’s quite clear that it would have been lovely for a Glasgow club to go into the Premiership and teams not to have to travel on the A9.

“I get that, but this is a great place and a great club. When players come up they realise what a great place it is and how good the people are running it.”

Thistle had won their previous five play-off games, netting 18 goals in the process, and bounced back from the late blow to produce the better football and the best chance of extra time, which Stuart Bannigan missed.

Manager Kris Doolan said: “I’m devastated as you would imagine. I’m gutted for everyone to be honest because we put so much into the games.

“Half the country was probably behind us, not just Partick Thistle fans. Football is cruel and I know it’s cruel but to go out on penalty-kicks is worse because you feel as if you were so close.”

Three VAR reviews all went against Thistle. They had a penalty claim denied despite Nick Walsh being called to the monitor to view Nohan Kenneh felling Ross Docherty.

Brian Graham was penalised after the ball hit his arm, and County captain Keith Watson had a red card rescinded after bringing down Thistle’s goalscorer, Scott Tiffoney.

“The one on Docherty, I couldn’t understand why it wasn’t given,” Doolan said. “From where we were it was blatant penalty.

“When he is brought over to the monitor you assume, it’s pretty blatant because it has been flagged up so I couldn’t understand why it wasn’t given.

“I don’t want to make excuses just on VAR, I feel like you would always be picking on VAR when we lost control of the game at times, five to 10 minutes when they score really quickly. We could have done better.

“Even in extra time we had a couple of chances which we could have scored and I was confident we would have taken one of them. It wasn’t to be, it just wasn’t our day.”

Related News

Brian Barry-Murphy, head coach, Cardiff City. Pic. Alamy

Brian Barry-Murphy Still in the Dark Over Cardiff City Transfer Ban

Brian Barry-Murphy has admitted he has no idea when Cardiff City’s transfer embargo will be lifted.

Gareth James | 1 hour ago
Vitor Matos Manager of Swansea City embraces Ji-Sung Eom of Swansea City. Pic: Alamy

Vitor Matos Could be Championship Manager of the Month for December . . . and Maybe January, too

Vitor Matos has been nominated for the Championship manager of the month award for December after four wins from six games, as Ian Mitchelmore reports.

Ian Mitchelmore | 5 hours ago
Christian Fuchs, manager of Newport County. Pic. Alamy

James Crole Aims to Prove Cymru Premier Goals Can Transform into Newport County Survival

James Crole insists his move to Newport County is the natural next step in a journey shaped by rising standards in the Cymru Premier, as Paul Jones reports.

Paul Jones | 20 hours ago
FAW chief executive Noel Mooney. Pic: Alamy

FAW and Noel Mooney Have Plenty to Aim for and Improve in 2026

Noel Mooney may have penned a new deal with the FAW last week, but the progress made in many areas needs to be reflected across the whole of Welsh football, reports Ian Mitchelmore.

Ian Mitchelmore | Jan 14, 2026
Jesurun Rak-Sakyi in action for Sheffield United. Pic. Alamy

Swansea City Still Hopeful of Signing Crystal Palace’s Jesurun Rak-Sakyi

Swansea City are still keen on signing Crystal Palace winger Jesurun Rak-Sakyi on loan, despite Vitor Matos suggesting other clubs were in the queue.

Gareth James | Jan 14, 2026
Wrexham goalkeeper Arthur Okonkwo celebrates with teammates. Pic: Alamy.

Wrexham’s Greatest . . . The Five Wonders of the Phil Parkinson Universe

Whenever Wrexham appear to have hit their peak, Phil Parkinson's side go on to achieve the unthinkable, as Ian Mitchelmore reports.

Ian Mitchelmore | Jan 13, 2026