The Welsh Rugby Union has outlined plans to reduce Wales’ four professional men’s rugby sides to three by 2027 - or possibly even 2028 — but key details of how the overhaul will actually work remain unclear, leaving many across the game confused and frustrated.
The WRU says its decision follows months of consultation with clubs, players and stakeholders after initial proposals to cut the professional game from four sides to two were met with fierce criticism.
That plan, labelled an “optimal solution” by the Union earlier this year, has now been scrapped.
However, while the governing body insists its new three-club model represents a more “sustainable” vision for the future, questions still surround which teams will survive, when the changes will take effect, and how the transition will be managed.
“Our decision is that the future structure of elite men’s rugby will be based on three professional men’s clubs, replacing the current four-team model, alongside two women’s elite teams,” said WRU chair Richard Collier-Keywood.
The Union intends to grant three licences — one each for the capital, west Wales and east Wales — with equal funding of £6.4m per team, rising to £7.8m annually.
Dragons and Cardiff, now owned by the WRU, are guaranteed funding through to 2028 having signed an agreement earlier this year, but the Scarlets and Ospreys’ current deals expire a year earlier.
That effectively leaves one of the two west Wales regions facing extinction, though the WRU has not yet explained how or when that decision will be made.
Collier-Keywood defended the Union’s handling of the process amid claims that its strategy has been confusing and poorly communicated.
“Definitely,” he said when asked if his position was tenable.
“I don’t accept it’s a mess at all. We went out with a consultation that had radical proposals… it was good to have debate… that’s absolutely necessary if we’re going to make change. We’re going to take people with us in that change… I have fun in this job every day.”
That sentiment was echoed by WRU director of rugby and elite performance Dave Reddin, who insisted the latest plan had been carefully constructed.
“Absolutely [my job is tenable],” Reddin said.
“The two-club model was predicated on the budget at the time… the union looked really hard at finances… when you look at level of investment, I’m massively excited about that. I don’t see a mess at all.”
READ MORE - Welcome to the WRU's New Show . . . Squid Game
Reddin said the new framework was “built from the ground up to drive success” and intended to “raise standards, restore the DNA of Welsh rugby and deliver the step forward in performance that everyone in Welsh rugby craves.”
He also acknowledged that the WRU had backtracked on its earlier stance after the strength of public opposition.
“We have heard loud and clear from the consultation that people want a long-term fix and not a short-term patch,” said Collier-Keywood. “We have listened and we agree.”
“Any change is difficult, and we have current contractual obligations to the URC and our professional clubs that we will honour in the absence of new agreements.
“We want to involve the URC and the owners and managers of the current clubs in how we get to our chosen destination. This may take some time, but we will work hard to get this done as quickly as possible.
“If, however, it ultimately proves impossible to reach a consensus on how this change will happen then the WRU will run a fair and transparent tendering process for the three licences. We have already guaranteed that all existing player contracts will be honoured.”
Asked about the timetable for the changes, the Collier-Keywood was at a loss to give an exact date over exactky how much notice the WRU are required to give the current 16-team URC
"Our contract with the URC is kind of like a forever contract," said Collier-Keywood.
"That's our obligation within that URC contract.”
"Ideally, it would be great to do them by next season, but can I promise we can do that? Absolutely not.
"We have to work with the URC. It's probably more realistic to expect it's going to be over more than one year. We have to work with the four professional clubs. We take our obligations very seriously, but we do want to put a line in the sand of what we believe is the right future structure for rugby and the fans.”
The WRU also pledged £40m of additional investment into player development and pathways over the next five years, including new men’s and women’s national academies, regional training centres, and enhanced youth systems.
Despite the financial commitment, the overall proposal still lacks clarity.
There is no definitive timeline for implementation, no indication of which region will be cut, and no clear sense of how a three-team competition structure will integrate within the United Rugby Championship.
While the WRU insists the plan will create a “joined-up, sustainable system,” the path to that outcome remains anything but straightforward — leaving Welsh rugby with more questions than answers.
