• Home
  • Rugby
  • Six Nations Chiefs Probe France Over Replacement Tactic That Left Rob Howley Outraged

Six Nations Chiefs Probe France Over Replacement Tactic That Left Rob Howley Outraged

Rob Howley - 2019 - Credit Simon King Replay Images

Rob Howley - 2019 - Credit Simon King Replay Images

Six Nations chiefs have launched an investigation into France’s controversial replacement switch against Wales. Tournament officials are to probe the circumstances behind the replacement of Uini Atonio by Rabah Slimani in the closing stages of their victory over Wales last month in a match that lasted 100 minutes.

Six Nations chiefs have launched an investigation into France’s controversial replacement switch against Wales.

Tournament officials are to probe the circumstances behind the replacement of Uini Atonio by Rabah Slimani in the closing stages of their victory over Wales last month in a match that lasted 100 minutes.

Slimani had already been substituted but the superior scrummager was allowed to return to the field when France’s team doctor sent Atonio for a head injury assessment in the 81st minute.

After the 20-18 defeat in Paris – that condemned Wales to a fifth-place finish – coach Rob Howley questioned the integrity of the French use of their bench and said: “There is evidence to suggest the integrity of the game has been brought into disrepute.”

Now, France’s move has been referred to the tournament’s Untoward Incident Review Group. Organisers have now finished their initial assessment of the incident and have decided a further review is needed.

A Six Nations statement said: “Following its preliminary investigation into the replacements made in the latter stages of the France v Wales match on 18 March 2017 (and in particular the replacement of Uini Atonio by Rabah Slimani), Six Nations Rugby has decided to refer the matter to the independent Six Nations Untoward Incident Review Group (UIRG) for review.

“Six Nations Rugby will send the file to the UIRG later this week and it is anticipated that the review process will begin shortly thereafter.”

In a chaotic finish, Wales wing George North claimed he was bitten by an opponent – although citing commissioner John Montgomery decided video footage was inconclusive and no further action was taken.

France forward Yoann Maestri was also fined 30,000 euros (£26,000) after he accepted a misconduct charge following allegedly critical post-match comments he made to the media about referee Wayne Barnes.

 

Related News

The Principality Stadium staged World Cup matches in 1999, 2007 and 2015. Pic. Alamy

Wales Face Big World Cup Wait as Argentina Launch Bid for 2035

Wales could be facing a wait of more than a decade to host another Rugby World Cup match if Argentina’s ambitious bid for the 2035 tournament is successful.

David Williams | Mar 18, 2026
Cardiff Coach, Corniel van Zyl. Pic. Inpho Photography

Cardiff’s Corniel van Zyl Ready to Tame Bulls on Return to Home Ring

With the Six Nations over, the Welsh regions return to action this weekend and for Cardiff head coach Corniel van Zyl that means a long trip home, as Simon Thomas reports.

Simon Thomas | Mar 17, 2026
Aaron Wainwright of Wales. Pic. Alamy

Aaron Wainwright Credits Steve Tandy for Wales’ Six Nations Turnaround

Aaron Wainwright has praised the leadership and culture created by head coach Steve Tandy as Wales look towards building on their victory over Italy.

Paul Jones | Mar 16, 2026
Wales coach Steve Tandy. Pic: Alamy

Steve Tandy Insists Wales Win Must Now Bring Turnaround

Steve Tandy has told Wales they have to build on their first Six Nations victory for three years, even though it came on the final day of this year’s tournament.

Graham Thomas | Mar 14, 2026
Dan Edwards celebrates his drop goal. Pic: Alamy

Wales' "Journey" Finally Leaves the Station as Italy are Left Stranded

As the great rugby revolutionary Mao Zedong once famously declared: "A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single home victory against Italy.”

Graham Thomas | Mar 14, 2026
Wales' Tomos Williams. Pic: Simon King

Tomos Williams Tells Wales: Be More Italy

Wales scrum-half Tomos Williams believes his team can draw inspiration from Italy’s recent revival as they attempt to end their dreadful losing streak in the Six Nations this weekend.

Paul Jones | Mar 14, 2026