• Home
  • Rugby
  • Ross Moriarty Should Be Judged By The Eye, Not The Machine

Ross Moriarty Should Be Judged By The Eye, Not The Machine

As Rob Howley and his coaches churn through the stats before picking their team to face Ireland – then pour over them again during the game – Peter Jackson points to a country where Ross Moriarty’s contribution would be measured by the eyes, rather than a computer. Kieran Read stands out in a land of giants for a reason other than his status as leader of the best team on the planet. His name springs to mind over the chorus of international coaches babbling on about the Test arena having escalated into a 23-man game. In that event, nobody has told the captain of New Zealand… and nobody will.

As Rob Howley and his coaches churn through the stats before picking their team to face Ireland – then pour over them again during the game – Peter Jackson points to a country where Ross Moriarty’s contribution would be measured by the eyes, rather than a computer.

 

Kieran Read stands out in a land of giants for a reason other than his status as leader of the best team on the planet. His name springs to mind over the chorus of international coaches babbling on about the Test arena having escalated into a 23-man game.    In that event, nobody has told the captain of New Zealand… and nobody will.

The obsession with substituting around five-eighths of every pack in every international does not apply to Read. The Global Positioning System (GPS) may have been behind Ross Moriarty’s absurdly early exit against England but no machine will ever tell the All Blacks to give their skipper the shepherd’s crook.

In a Six Nations where coaches talk of “emptying the tank” as if certain players in certain positions are not fuelled to go the distance, Read stands apart – the supreme 80-minute man, the one who never runs out of gas.

At a time when more and more forwards seem programmed for no longer than an hour at most, the double World Cup winners assume that their totemic No.8 will be there from start to finish, and at every point in between.

Since August 2015 the All Blacks have played 25 Tests. Read has played every minute of every one, except for the last five against Argentina in Buenos Aires last summer when, the game safely won, they hauled him off to give Elliot Dixon the briefest of runs.

No European player has made a better fist at keeping up with Read than Jamie Heaslip. The Irish Lion, as durable as ever at 33, confronted France yesterday having missed fewer than 40 minutes over the course of his last 19 Tests.

A coterie of other second-cum-back row players are in the habit of lasting the full 80 more often than not – Maro Itoje and Billy Vunipola from England, Ireland’s Devin Toner and CJ Stander, the Scotland lock Johnny Gray, his French counterpart Yoann Maestri and the Springbok Eben Etzebeth.

Despite recent events, Wales can add two of their own to that list. Taulupe Faletau was positively Read-like until his transfer from the Dragons to Bath coincided with a few dents going into his aura of indestructibility.

Ross Moriarty is the other, ironically so given that Wales now say that the data from the GPS gadget tucked into his jersey showed an empty tank. And this from a player who played every minute of all three Tests in New Zealand on successive Saturdays last summer.

It begs a nagging question about who makes the call – the coach or the machine?

Over the past 12 months, only four players have completed ten or more Tests without being bothered by an official raising their number in neon on a touchline board. Heaslip and the Kiwi lock Sam Whitelock have ten to their game, the redoubtable Wallaby flanker Michael Hooper has 11, one behind the untouchable Read.

Over those same 12 months, front row forwards putting in 80 minutes can be counted on the fingers of two hands.

Dan Cole, the England tighthead, and Ireland’s loosehead Jack McGrath have done it three times each, Gethin Jenkins, Tomas Francis (both Wales), Zander Fagerson (Scotland), Scott Sio, Sekope Kepu (both Australia) and Werner Koch (South Africa) once.

Even fewer hookers have managed it – Adriaan Strauss (South Africa), Steven Moore (Australia), Rory Best (Ireland), Guilhem Guirado (France) and Dane Coles (New Zealand). It almost creates a nostalgia for the old days when subs referred to underwater boats and teams finished exactly as they had started.

England, glory be, did manage that once during the professional era, against Argentina in Buenos Aires in June 2002 when their reserves won, 26-18. Despite picking five new caps (Michael Horak, Geoff Appleford, Ben Johnston, Phil Christophers and Alex Codling), Clive Woodward refused to use any of the seven subs.

It could never happen again, not now that the game has been taken over by heartless computers with the capacity to tell the coach when someone’s time is up.

 

Related News

The Principality Stadium staged World Cup matches in 1999, 2007 and 2015. Pic. Alamy

Wales Face Big World Cup Wait as Argentina Launch Bid for 2035

Wales could be facing a wait of more than a decade to host another Rugby World Cup match if Argentina’s ambitious bid for the 2035 tournament is successful.

David Williams | 4 hours ago
Cardiff Coach, Corniel van Zyl. Pic. Inpho Photography

Cardiff’s Corniel van Zyl Ready to Tame Bulls on Return to Home Ring

With the Six Nations over, the Welsh regions return to action this weekend and for Cardiff head coach Corniel van Zyl that means a long trip home, as Simon Thomas reports.

Simon Thomas | Mar 17, 2026
Aaron Wainwright of Wales. Pic. Alamy

Aaron Wainwright Credits Steve Tandy for Wales’ Six Nations Turnaround

Aaron Wainwright has praised the leadership and culture created by head coach Steve Tandy as Wales look towards building on their victory over Italy.

Paul Jones | Mar 16, 2026
Wales coach Steve Tandy. Pic: Alamy

Steve Tandy Insists Wales Win Must Now Bring Turnaround

Steve Tandy has told Wales they have to build on their first Six Nations victory for three years, even though it came on the final day of this year’s tournament.

Graham Thomas | Mar 14, 2026
Dan Edwards celebrates his drop goal. Pic: Alamy

Wales' "Journey" Finally Leaves the Station as Italy are Left Stranded

As the great rugby revolutionary Mao Zedong once famously declared: "A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single home victory against Italy.”

Graham Thomas | Mar 14, 2026
Wales' Tomos Williams. Pic: Simon King

Tomos Williams Tells Wales: Be More Italy

Wales scrum-half Tomos Williams believes his team can draw inspiration from Italy’s recent revival as they attempt to end their dreadful losing streak in the Six Nations this weekend.

Paul Jones | Mar 14, 2026