• Home
  • Football
  • Yousef Salech Is The Fourth Most Fouled Player In League One This Season . . . So Is Brian Barry Murphy Right Or Wrong?

Yousef Salech is the Fourth Most Fouled Player in League One this Season . . . so is Brian Barry-Murphy Right or Wrong?

Yousef Salech of Cardiff City. Pic. Alamy

Yousef Salech of Cardiff City. Pic. Alamy

Yousef Salech was in the eye of a storm at the weekend . . . in more ways than one, as Ian Mitchelmore reports.

Following the initial deep concern at seeing Yousef Salech being carried off the pitch on a stretcher while wearing a neck brace, all connected to Cardiff City will have been immensely relieved to hear later in the day that the striker had not suffered a serious injury.

The forward was left on the ground following a collision with Brad Hills during the Bluebirds' 1-1 draw with Stockport County at Cardiff City Stadium on Saturday.

After a 13-minute delay while the 24-year-old received treatment, the Danish front man was taken to hospital for further assessment.

READ MORE: Yousef Salech Gives Cardiff City Huge Boost as Brian Barry-Murphy Anger Lingers

Fortunately, the club gave a positive update little more than three hours after full time.

"We’re pleased to inform supporters that Yousef Salech has been discharged from hospital without any serious injury and will now observe a short period of rest and recovery," a club statement read.

The incident prompted a strong response from head coach Brian Barry-Murphy who stated the injury to Salech had "been coming".

"We've seen for months that he (Salech) hasn't been protected by the referees.

"It definitely wasn't nice viewing. It's very difficult when you have such a serious injury to someone who's so close to all the players."

READ MORE: Gosh, it’s the Real Osh . . . Cardiff City Man Gabriel is Back With a Bang

Hills was not penalised for the incident, and referee Paul Howard did not award the Bluebirds a free-kick.

So does Barry-Murphy have a point when it comes to his claims that Salech needs more protection from officials?

According to Opta, Salech has been fouled 51 times in League One so far this season. 

For context,  Stockport's Kyle Wootton (63), Exeter City's Jayden Wareham (57) and Lincoln City's Freddie Draper (53) have been fouled more in the third tier so far this term.

READ MORE: The Wheels Seem to be Staying Firmly on at Cardiff City

It remains to be seen whether or not the Bluebirds plan to have, or have had, discussions with the Football Association on the matter, although the fact Barry-Murphy referenced in his post-match press conference that Salech has been a target for some time was telling.

"We do so much analysis on the games. If I'm an opposing manager or an opposing team, I'll see what you can and can't get away with against a player with his profile," said the Irishman.

"It's been coming for months where he's been consistently fouled. There's a lot of talk about what the threshold is this season - the level of contact can be prolonged in more than previous years. It's got ridiculous. 

"He's clearly been fouled all the time and not got any free-kicks. The interpretation of the new rules is up to the referees, but it's clear how much you can and can't get away with and the level of challenges that he's consistently facing are clearly fouls and not being punished."

But the change in interpretation Barry-Murphy is talking about is not something that has been sprung upon unsuspecting managers this season.

From 2023, the English Football League stated their desire for the flow of matches to be as swift as possible.

As a result, their rules state the following: "As attempts continue to be made to keep the game flowing, a high threshold for penalising contact will remain, with officials not awarding a foul for all contact, yet penalising when contact has a detrimental impact on an opponent." 

Quite what that guidance means in reality, though, is still a matter for referees to decide.

Detrimental? How detrimental? Detrimental to a player’s health or to his chances of scoring or setting up a chance for a teammate?

Salech’s confrontation with Hills produced plenty of debate, but no clear verdict over whether Hills was using his arms in order to challenge for the ball, or to create “a detrimental impact” on Salech. 

The only thing that is clear is that Salech has been one of the shining lights this term and has unquestionably been pivotal for Cardiff, scoring 12 goals in the league and featuring in all 27 matches in the third tier under Barry-Murphy. 

Ultimately, the news that he is not seriously injured was the most important factor.

But when it comes to Cardiff and Barry-Murphy, a dossier may well need to be sent to the powers that be at the FA as the club look to ensure their players are given the best protection possible moving forward.

 

Related News

Antoine Semenyo of Ghana. Pic: Alamy

Wales Planning World Cup Farewell Party . . . if They Make the Guest List

Wales are determined to host a pre-World Cup party if they make it to the 2026 finals this summer.

David Williams | 15 hours ago
Davis Keillor-Dunn of Barnsley. Pic. Alamy

Wrexham Lead the Way in Welsh Window Clean up

There were mixed fortunes for Wales' four EFL clubs on transfer deadline day as plenty of business was conducted as Ian Mitchelmore reports.

Ian Mitchelmore | Feb 03, 2026
Tottenham Hotspur defender Ben Davies. Pic. Alamy

Ben Davies Could Still Make World Cup, Insists Wales Boss Craig Bellamy

The race against time by Ben Davies, to recover from a serious ankle injury has become a central concern for Wales as the World Cup play-offs edge closer.

Paul Jones | Feb 03, 2026
New Wrexham signing Zak Vyner. Pic: Alamy

Zak Vyner gets his Dream Move . . . Wrexham

Zak Vyner’s long-standing admiration for Wrexham from a distance has become close range after the defender completed a move from Bristol City.

David Williams | Feb 02, 2026
Calum Scanlon in action for Liverpool. Pic: Alamy

Calum Scanlon is a Cardiff City Fan

Cardiff City’s commitment to progressive, entertaining football under Brian Barry-Murphy, helped persuade Calum Scanlon to join on loan from Liverpool.

Paul Jones | Feb 02, 2026
Swansea City head coach Vitor Matos. Pic: Alamy

Vitor Matos Insists the Foundations are Being Laid at Swansea City

Vitor Matos believes he is now laying down lasting building blocks at Swansea City after a significant 2-0 Championship win away at Watford.

David Williams | Feb 01, 2026