• Home
  • Football
  • Pembrokeshire Football Title Decision Embroiled In Player Eligibility Controversy

Pembrokeshire Football Title Decision Embroiled in Player Eligibility Controversy

By Fraser Watson A row has broken out over player eligibility rules, which has prevented a Pembrokeshire club from clinching the title. The Division 1 season may be over in the Pembrokeshire Football League – but it could be sometime before the champions are confirmed with both the top two clubs potentially facing sanctions. As […]

By Fraser Watson

A row has broken out over player eligibility rules, which has prevented a Pembrokeshire club from clinching the title.

The Division 1 season may be over in the Pembrokeshire Football League – but it could be sometime before the champions are confirmed with both the top two clubs potentially facing sanctions.

As things stand, it’s Goodwick United who have finished top from Hakin by three points following an unbeaten campaign. The two met at The Obs earlier this month in a game which on paper, The Vikings had to win to keep their title hopes alive.

It ended 1-1, which in normal circumstances would have been enough to see Goodwick crowned champions, giving them a 13 point cushion with Hakin only able to take 12 from their four remaining matches in hand.

They went on to take 10 points from them, following a draw at Clarbeston Road and wins over Pennar, Merlins Bridge, and Fishguard – leaving them three off the pace.

However, prior to that Hakin v Goodwick match it emerge the Phoenix Boys were being investigated by the League authority for the possible fielding of an ineligible player(s) in their win 5-2 over Carew on April 9. Were they to be found guilty and that result reversed to a defeat – it would be enough for Hakin to take the title on goal difference.

The situation is complicated further though by the prospect of Hakin themselves also being penalised. During that clash with Goodwick, the play was held up for several minutes after a home spectator was alleged to have entered onto the field of play and struck an away player.

The incident was included in the referee’s report and is currently being investigated by the West Wales Football Association.

Were Hakin to receive any deduction of points as a punishment, Goodwick would remain champions irrespective of losing their win over Carew.

Both the Pembrokeshire and West Wales authorities have declined to comment publicly on either investigation, but both clubs will receive the opportunity to respond to any charges.

The developments have overshadowed what was an enthralling title race, with Goodwick’s 2-1 win over Hakin at Phoenix Park back on October 30 proving the only difference between the sides.

At The Obs they led 1-0 early on from Sion O’Sullivan’s volley, before Leon Luby levelled for the hosts in injury time when his long range free kick evaded everyone in the area and found the top corner.

Related News

Brian Barry-Murphy, head coach, Cardiff City. Pic. Alamy

Brian Barry-Murphy Tells his Cardiff City Players: This Isn’t Good Enough

Cardiff City manager Brian Barry-Murphy has admitted his side just aren’t good enough at present after they lost for the fourth time in six matches.

Gareth James | 9 hours ago
What's on in Wales

DragonSports Welsh Sporting Calendar

Craig Bellamy will attempt to steer Wales towards a World Cup play-off place when his team resume their qualification campaign in Liechtenstein on Saturday.

David Williams | 12 hours ago
Alan Sheehan, the head coach/manager of Swansea city. Pic. Alamy

Alan Sheehan Admits Only Wins Can Save Him as Swansea City Stall Again

Alan Sheehan has admitted he is a man under pressure after a fifth defeat in his last eight matches in charge of Swansea City.

David Roberts | 12 hours ago
JD Cymru North

Holywell Town Aim to Bounce Back After Airbus Attack

The JD Cymru North is hotting up nicely at the top with three clubs - Llandudno, Airbus UK Broughton and Holywell Town - all bunched together as we head towards the season mid-point.

Dave Jones | Nov 08, 2025
Brian Barry-Murphy, the Cardiff City Manager. Pic. Alamy

Cardiff City Have Bounce Back Factor That Can Squash Tangerines, Says Brian Barry-Murphy

Cardiff City boss Brian Barry-Murphy says he has full faith in his squad’s ability to rebound from adversity as the Bluebirds prepare to face Blackpool away on Saturday.

Paul Jones | Nov 08, 2025
David Hughes, manager of Newport County. Pic: Alamy

David Hughes Insists Only Regular Victories Count as a Revival

Newport County manager David Hughes says his side must string together more victories before anyone can talk about a genuine turnaround in fortunes.

Graham Thomas | Nov 08, 2025