• Home
  • Rugby
  • Dwayne Peel’S “Soft” Scarlets Reach New Low Point Of Awful Season

Dwayne Peel’s “Soft” Scarlets Reach New Low Point Of Awful Season

Dwayne Peel - Credit Andrew Orchard Alamy

Dwayne Peel - Credit Andrew Orchard Alamy

The Scarlets miserable season continued as they were beaten 31-19 in their fourth and final EPCR Challenge Cup pool match as 13-man Edinburgh romped into the Round of 16. This latest defeat left the Scarlets anchored to the bottom of Pool 3 as they were outgunned by five tries to three.

By Gareth James

The Scarlets miserable season continued as they were beaten 31-19 in their fourth and final EPCR Challenge Cup pool match as 13-man Edinburgh romped into the Round of 16.

This latest defeat left the Scarlets anchored to the bottom of Pool 3 as they were outgunned by five tries to three.

In doing so they became the first Welsh region to fail to register a point in a European campaign.

“I was disappointed with the first half, we gave them too many soft points. Physically they dominated the middle of the field and we couldn’t get speed of ball,” admitted Scarlets head coach Dwayne Peel.

“That ultimately hurt us, although when we did get speed of ball we did get to the edges. The likes of Joe Roberts looked threatening and Tomi Lewis is coming on as well.

“We piggy-backed them up the field and that’s the disappointing part for me. We have got to get better than that.”

https://twitter.com/scarlets_rugby/status/1748465693626880015?s=20

Edinburgh finished with 13 players as Grant Gilchrist was given a second yellow card in the 72nd minute.

Then the visitors lost Scotland and British & Irish Lions wing Duhan van der Merwe to the sin bin at the end of the game.

Earlier, hooker Dave Cherry was also shown a yellow card which meant Edinburgh played almost 30 minutes with 14 men and then a couple with only 13..

https://twitter.com/scarlets_rugby/status/1748447584476160500?s=20

Ben Vellacott, WP Nel, Duhan van de Merwe, Hamish Watson and Schoeman scored the visitors’ tries, while Roberts and Ryan Conbeer scored for Scarlets, who were also awarded a penalty try at the death.

Edinburgh needed a bonus-point win to guarantee them a play-off lace and they got off to the perfect star when scrum half Vellacott crashed over in their first visit to the Scarlets 22. A few minutes later Nel got another.

They had bagged the bonus-point just after the half-hour mark and it was 26-5 in Edinburgh’s favour at the break. It was a similar story in the second half as Edinburgh maintained their advantage as Schuman bagged another try three minutes after the interval.

Scarlets at least gained some respect on the scoreboard with two tries in the final four minutes, but it was much too little far too late.

https://twitter.com/BBCScrumV/status/1748471111711375825?s=20

Related News

Wales players feel the pain of another defeat. Pic: Alamy

Steve Tandy Tastes Defeat Again But Wales' Progress Sweetens the Medicine

Steve Tandy believes Wales are moving firmly in the right direction, even though the downward descent in the results chart continued with defeat to Ireland.

David Williams | 7 hours ago
Llandovery celebrate winning the SRC Cup last year. Pic: WRU

Newport Believe They have Wind in their Sails to Blow Away Holders Llandovery in SCR Cup Showdown

Newport RFC will head into Saturday’s Super Rygbi Cup final at Cardiff Arms Park believing they have the momentum to challenge holders Llandovery RFC.

David Parsons | 7 hours ago
Wales team training. Pic. Alamy

Wales Aim for Progress and Hope it Might Somehow be Enough to Overcome Ireland

Wales head to Dublin on Friday night hoping that signs of progress shown a fortnight ago can finally translate into a result, when they face resurgent Ireland.

Graham Thomas | Mar 06, 2026
Wales forward James Botham. Pic: Alamy

James Botham Forced to Listen to the Word of the Lord (Botham)

The FaceTime call from Australia was always coming — and James Botham knew it.

Graham Thomas | Mar 05, 2026
Ireland head coach Andy Farrell. Pic. Alamy

Andy Farrell Insists Wales are not as Bad as the Statistics Suggest

Andy Farrell believes Wales are arriving in Dublin with belief and momentum, claiming reports of the death of a rugby nation have been greatly exaggerated.

Paul Jones | Mar 05, 2026
Wales wing Ellis Mee. Pic: Alamy

Steve Tandy Admits Wales' Targets Have not Changed Ahead of Ireland Test

Wales head coach Steve Tandy has made it clear that his focus ahead of Friday night’s trip to Dublin is not bold talk of victory, but ensuring his side are “competitive”.

Graham Thomas | Mar 04, 2026