• Home
  • Football
  • A Red Card For Gareth Bale May Have Prevented Seamus Coleman Injury, Says Martin O’Neill

A Red Card For Gareth Bale May Have Prevented Seamus Coleman Injury, Says Martin O’Neill

Gareth Bale, Welsh Former Footballer. Pic: Every Second Media/Alamy Live News/Every Second Media

Gareth Bale, Welsh Former Footballer. Pic: Every Second Media/Alamy Live News/Every Second Media

Martin O’Neill has claimed Seamus Coleman’s broken leg may not have happened if Gareth Bale had been sent off moments earlier in Wales’ World Cup qualifier against the Republic of Ireland. As the accusations and recriminations continue following last Friday’s clash in Dublin, the Ireland manager has suggested a Bale sending off may have cooled the temperature of a fiery match that was over-heating.

Martin O’Neill has claimed Seamus Coleman’s broken leg may not have happened if Gareth Bale had been sent off moments earlier in Wales’ World Cup qualifier against the Republic of Ireland.

As the accusations and recriminations continue following last Friday’s clash in Dublin, the Ireland manager has suggested a Bale sending off may have cooled the temperature of a fiery match that was over-heating.

The Real Madrid star was booked for a rash challenge on defender John O’Shea seconds before team-mate Taylor launched the tackle which left Coleman with a double leg fracture during the 0-0 draw at the Aviva Stadium.

Asked if he thought there was a possibility that Coleman might not have suffered his injury had referee Nicola Rizzoli taken stronger action moments earlier against Bale, O’Neill said: “He may not have done, that is true.

“The referee is in charge of the game, that’s the point. As I mentioned there, I thought both challenges, when I have seen them back, have been very, very poor indeed.”

Wales boss Chris Coleman later defended both men – by his own admission having not had a chance to view replays of the two incidents – and revealed Bale had raised the possibility of contesting the yellow card which will see him miss June’s trip to Group D leaders Serbia through suspension, although an appeal can only be made on the grounds of mistaken identity.

But O’Neill added: “I can’t see how they could possibly think about appealing a card when it was very, very close to being red and on another day, the referee could have easily given a red card.

“I will reiterate – I don’t think anybody could disagree – both challenges were very, very poor.”

Seamus Coleman faces a lengthy spell on the sidelines as he recovers from surgery to pin the broken tibia and fibula in his right leg with O’Neill bemoaning the loss of ‘one of the best full-backs in Europe’.

The manager is not putting any time-frame on the Everton defender’s rehabilitation but is all but resigned to his absence for the remainder of the qualifying campaign, with Derby’s Cyrus Christie likely to get a chance to prove himself as his deputy in Tuesday night’s friendly against Iceland.

O’Neill added: “We have got games coming up in September and October and my own view is that I think it would be a long shot if he was making those games.

“Seamus is very hard to replace – he is one of the best full-backs in Europe – and he has been inspirational, really, particularly since he has taken over as captain. He has been terrific, so he will be very hard to replace.

“Cyrus Christie is a very, very good player, a very talented player, very strong going forward and it’s really up to him.

“I think he is capable of talking that step and the times that he’s played for us before, he’s done very well. He scored a very important goal against Gibraltar (during qualifying for Euro 2016) in the away game and a couple of minutes later, he headed one off the line, so he has had a contribution and it is up to him now.”

 

Related News

Ashley Phillips, Stoke City. Pic. Alamy

Wales Hope Swansea Way Will Prove a Wales Route for Ashley Phillips

Craig Bellamy is hoping Ashley Phillips’ strong Swansea links convince the Tottenham Hotspur defender to switch back to Wales from England.

Paul Jones | 1 hour ago
Liam Cullen of Swansea City (20). Pic. Alamy

Swansea City’s Liam Cullen . . . Instinct of a Marksman, Patience of a Saint

Liam Cullen says scoring spectacular goals and influencing games from the bench is hugely satisfying — but he still wants to start matches for club and country.

Graham Thomas | 23 hours ago
Flint Town United players celebrate on their way to a 5-1 victory over Bangor City. Pic: FAW

Caernarfon and Flint Flex Muscle to Reach Welsh Cup Final

An all-JD Cymru Premier showdown will decide this season’s Welsh Cup.

David Williams | Mar 09, 2026
Mared Griffiths of Wales. Pic. Alamy

Mared Griffiths Steps into Jess Fishlock’s Shoes . . . and Looks Pretty Good for Wales

Rhian Wilkinson has hailed teenage forward Mared Griffiths as an exciting glimpse of the future of Welsh football.

Hannah Blackwell | Mar 09, 2026
Wrexham's George Dobson gets a red card after a VAR check. Pic: Alamy

Not Clear, Not Obvious . . . Wrexham Boss Phil Parkinson Sceptical Over VAR Role in FA Cup Defeat

Wrexham went out of the FA Cup swinging and manager Phil Parkinson continued to throw some heavy combinations after the final whistle.

David Williams | Mar 08, 2026
Dom Jefferies scores Lincoln City's second goal against Cardiff City. Pic: Alamy

Brian Barry-Murphy Insists Cardiff City Setback will not Lead to a Slide

Brian Barry-Murphy insists his side have repeatedly shown the ability to respond to adversity – and they can do it again.

Rob Cole | Mar 08, 2026